Descartes’ Intellectual Romance with a Princess
November 19, 2026
I have been mad at Descartes for decades. He tore mind from body, leaving us with a dualism that compartmentalized Western medicine and blinded us to the delicate interactions within what is, in truth, inextricable. But a single, very human question—was he in love with Elisabeth of Bohemia?—sent me to their correspondence. In those seven years of letters, Descartes is far less rigid and certain than I had supposed, and Elisabeth plays a powerful role in shaping his ideas.
A princess in exile, she was the daughter of Frederick V, briefly King of Bohemia, and the granddaughter of King James (VI of Scotland and I of England). No slouch, she studied five languages, history, logic, math, politics, philosophy, astronomy, and jurisprudence. She had read Descartes’ Meditations and, when he visited The Hague, where her family lived in exile, she listened rapt to his ideas. When he learned of her dee[ interest, he returned, but they did not manage to meet.
“I was elated by your kind willingness to share yourself with an ignorant and headstrong person,” she writes, “and saddened by the misfortune of missing such a profitable conversation.” A few more pleasantries, and she fires her question: “Given that the soul of a human being is only a thinking substance, how can it affect the bodily spirits, in order to bring about voluntary actions?”
Elisabeth wants “a definition of the soul that homes in on its nature more thoroughly than does the one you give in your Meditations.” Descartes has no such definition. He opens his reply with a handwritten stammer, saying that when he first saw her, he was so dazzled by her beauty and intelligence that he could not converse well. Then he tries to settle her question by saying that all we really know about the soul is “(1) the fact that it thinks, and (2) the fact that being united to the body it can act and be acted on along with it.” He admits saying virtually nothing of (2). He was eager to show that the soul was “distinct from the body,” he explains, and (2) would cloud the issue. “But,” he writes merrily, “I can’t hide anything from eyesight as sharp as yours!”
Wait, what? He deliberately left out the bit about the interaction of mind and body? That would have been nice to know sooner.
Descartes tries to show, by awkward analogy, how the soul moves the body. Elisabeth does not buy it. She opens her reply by thanking him for his flattery but assuring him that “the false praise wasn’t necessary.” She describes the life to which she is constrained, her tone a practiced faux-subordinate feminine strategy. “I hope that this will excuse my stupid inability to grasp what you want me to grasp,” she writes, because she cannot see how his analogy in any way explains “how the (nonextended and immaterial) soul can move the body.”
As Descartes tries again to explain his thinking, he says something incredibly interesting for a guy who was supposed to be splitting mind and soul from messy flesh: “The knowledge we get of what belongs to the soul’s union with the body is a very dark affair when it comes from the intellect (whether alone or aided by the imagination), but it is very bright when the senses have a hand in it. That’s why people who never come at things in a theoretical way and use only their senses have no doubt that the soul moves the body and that the body acts on the soul. They regard soul and body as a single thing, i.e. they conceive their union.”
Their intellectual banter is more than fond. “The biggest reward I have received from my published writings is that you have been so good as to read them,” he writes. In another letter, he calls her “incomparable”: “yours is the only intellect I have encountered that finds everything equally clear.” He describes her selfless compassion as “the most lovable of all your virtues.” He writes that he “can’t read the arguments in your letters without feeling an extraordinary joy.” And Elisabeth, the more reserved of the two, finally concedes, “You are right to believe that the divertissement that your letters bring me is different from the others that I have had on my way here, because it gives me a greater and more lasting satisfaction.”
Descartes is single, solitary, and twenty-two years Elisabeth’s senior. His only known affair was with an incredibly intelligent maid, Helena, who bore him a daughter. The child died of scarlet fever at age five, and Descartes wept freely, defying anyone to think him less manly for it.
Did he later fall in love with Elisabeth?
When he learns that she has been ill, he curses the solitude that delayed this discovery and gently tells her the cause must be sadness, because she has been so distressed over family issues. He stays politely vague, but her brother has, on the pretext of a duel for family honor, ambushed and killed a man who boasted of seducing another sister and their mother. The mother has decided that Elisabeth, with her cunning brilliance, put him up to it, and Elisabeth, who has no dowry or stable income, has been banished from the family court at The Hague.
Meanwhile, Descartes is inspired by her illness, and their sharp-witted exchanges, to write The Passions of the Soul, which he dedicates to her. Slowly, she is exposing flaws in his dualism and tugging him toward psychology, ethics, and human emotions. When he urges her to read the Stoics for strength, she counters that physical suffering and political hardship cannot be whisked away by pure willpower. He concedes her point.
Descartes was a commoner; they could never have married anyway. Still, the young, cerebral, unruly Queen Christina of Sweden was jealous of their relationship, and she sent a warship loaded with two thousand books to fetch him to Stockholm. Elisabeth fretted, knowing his poor health, and he, too, wound up regretting his decision. Queen Christina could only squeeze in her philosophy lessons at dawn, in a freezing castle. Descartes, who loved lying abed and loathed the cold, took a chill, developed pneumonia, and died.
Elisabeth went on without the comfort of his friendship, eventually becoming the Princess-Abbess of the Imperial Abbey of Herford. This gave her a power and intellectual independence she could never have had otherwise. She provided sanctuary for Quakers and other persecuted Protestant sects and continued her lively intellectual engagement with prominent thinkers.
But there was never another Descartes.






