Dating Apps’ Crimes of the Heart
How dating technologies satisfy our short-term criteria before robbing us of long-term relationships.
By Tolu Daniel
November 16, 2026
There are few things more difficult to recover than the things we once believed about love. Perhaps this is because, as we grow older, we begin acquiring new vocabularies for describing the things we desire. In the last decade, for instance, relationship vocabulary has expanded considerably. Word pairings like emotional availability, attachment styles, deal breakers, and red flags have entered the fray. We have become better at describing what we want, or at least better at explaining why someone else does not meet the requirements. Yet despite this arsenal of language, it remains questionable whether we have become any better at answering the age-old question of how to love one another.
I have sometimes wondered what our parents would make of the language we now use to describe the business of falling in love. What would they make of the idea that a person might be rejected because of their attachment style, their height, their photographs, the inadequacy of a three-line biography, or their inability to respond to a text on time? What about the gift (because I have heard it described as a gift) of being able to read nuance into a text message from someone who likes you but does not know how to tell you? Perhaps they would recognize the gig. After all, people have always had preferences, people have always found reasons to reject one another, and, as one of my best friends likes to say, people have been peopling from time immemorial. Yet I suspect they might be surprised by how much of the work of getting to know someone we have managed to accomplish before actually meeting them. We have developed elaborate ways of deciding whether a person is worth knowing, sometimes without allowing ourselves the opportunity to know them at all. We have never had more ways of finding one another, and yet I wonder whether we have become less willing to discover one another. The distance between those two propositions is where I have been thinking about love lately.
In Nigeria, one of the most enduring sounds of the generation before the arrival of what is today called Afrobeats arrived with 2Face Idibia, shortly after he broke away from the boyband Plantashun Boiz. With the release of his debut single Nfana Ibaga around May 2004 and, much later, African Queen, 2face announced his entry into the scene. Two years after the album that housed those two singles, he released If Love Is a Crime in 2006 to critical acclaim in his sophomore album Grass 2 Grace. The song particularly, became something of an anthem for those of us coming of age around that time. 2006 was a time of many firsts in the political and social life of any young Nigerian. We were firmly in the Fourth Republic. Chief Olusegun Obasanjo had a firm grip on Nigeria’s political atmosphere, having used his incumbency to secure a second term, and was now attempting a political rigmarole to get himself a third term, as many African political strongmen are wont to do.
People have always had preferences, people have always found reasons to reject one another, and, as one of my best friends likes to say, people have been peopling from time immemorial.
This timeline was the beginning of my own entry into teenage life. Having been newly matriculated as an undergrad at the newly formed Tai Solarin University of Education, my next plan was to fall in love. It seemed easy enough. I met a girl who, at the time, was the perfect example of what I believed my future was. She was tall, pretty, and had a smile ready-made for me every time I saw her. And 2face’s song, back then, despite their mostly cringey lyrics in retrospect, represented all the things I wanted to say to her. I believed then that I was utterly and totally in love. Perhaps this was because of how easy it seemed to fall for a person. All you had to do was meet them, speak with them, do the chicken dance (for that was what pursuing them was called), and hope that whatever emerged between you would eventually become something worth keeping.
Recently in a conversation with my friend and colleague Mary Cox, a PhD student in psychology and brain sciences at WashU, about what it means to fall in love in this era and the use of dating apps, she told me that “dating apps are commodifying women to be the products.” She explained that dating apps allow people to begin relationships in medias res, often starting with physical attraction and meeting in person already knowing that they find each other attractive. Meeting someone in person, by contrast, can allow you to spend time getting to know them, observing them long enough to decide whether they are worth pursuing. Of course, my 2face-music-inspired-attempt at a relationship with the girl from my undergrad was doomed for failure from day one because of how much I idealized her. However, the fact of getting to know her, of leaning into the process, is still one of my favorite things ever. I think about that song sometimes and wonder what exactly I heard in it back then. Perhaps it was the certainty of its declaration, the idea that love was something you could recognize almost immediately, something that announced itself with enough force to make all other considerations seem secondary. I was young enough to believe that feeling something intensely was a reasonable indication that I had discovered something worth keeping. I know better now, or at least I would like to think I do. But I sometimes wonder whether, in becoming more discerning about what we want from one another, we have also become less willing to entertain the possibility of being surprised by what we find.
In my first years fiddling with dating apps in the United States, living somewhere in Kansas, I quickly learned that the algorithms reflected the biases of the society I lived in. It was difficult to meet, let alone connect with, the kinds of people I would have preferred to meet. By this I mean that I could swipe right for days on a dating app and not get a single match. There were a few reasons for this. One had to do with my Blackness, or rather, my growing awareness of how my Blackness was being read in the society I now inhabited. I had not quite understood that the experience of being Black in the United States, particularly in a predominantly White town in Kansas, might shape the kinds of people who considered me desirable or even worth getting to know. I was learning, in other words, that the possibilities dating apps promised were not necessarily available to everyone in equal measure.
Most of my lasting relationships from that period, however, were with people I met in person, from the men who became my friends to the women I dated. There is something inherently special, I think, about seeing a person for the first time, observing them, appreciating the things you know about them and the things you are yet to discover. There is a joy in the finding out, in the gradual accumulation of details that make another person familiar to you, and in the occasional surprise of discovering that they are not quite who you had imagined them to be. What is criminal, and I mean that quite deliberately, is how we have gradually relegated this act of knowing, this desire to encounter another person, to a series of questions and answers. I know Big Dating Apps might come for me for saying this, but there is something reductive about the idea that a few questions, a handful of photographs, and a carefully assembled biography can tell us enough about another person to determine whether they are worth knowing. Perhaps the more troubling thing is how readily we mistake this information for knowledge, how quickly we allow ourselves to believe that because we have established someone’s preferences, their ambitions, their deal breakers, and the kind of relationship they are looking for, we have somehow encountered the person themselves. We can arrive at a first meeting already carrying the impression that we know the essential things about someone and begin imagining a life with them before we have had the opportunity to discover what it might actually mean to share one.
I sometimes wonder whether, in becoming more discerning about what we want from one another, we have also become less willing to entertain the possibility of being surprised by what we find.
I am reminded of an episode of HBO’s Game of Thrones, in which Tyrion Lannister, the dwarf son of one of Westeros’s most powerful families, played by Peter Dinklage, is arrested and unjustly accused of murdering his nephew. When given the opportunity to defend himself, Tyrion instead confesses to a different crime: being a dwarf. There is something about how the world can decide what your crime is before you have had a chance to explain yourself. I wonder sometimes whether something similar happens when we encounter people through dating apps. Before we have met them, before we have heard the peculiarities of their laughter or discovered what makes them impatient, before we have watched them struggle to explain something they care about, we have already begun making judgments. We know their height, perhaps their profession, the places they have visited, the books they claim to have read, the photographs they have chosen to represent themselves. We know whether they smoke, whether they want children, whether they are looking for something casual or something serious. We might even know their political preferences. We have assembled a little dossier and, from it, begun to decide whether this person deserves an encounter with us.
Of course, people have always judged one another. We carry our prejudices into bars, classrooms, parties, churches, and every other place where we might encounter a stranger. There is no magical space in which we meet another person free of our assumptions. The problem, perhaps, is that dating apps make those assumptions feel like sufficient grounds for a decision. They give us the impression that we have gathered enough information to know whether someone is worth our time before we have spent any time with them. The judgment arrives before the encounter, and the encounter, when it finally happens, must contend with the judgment we have already made. But have you ever asked yourself what it might mean to know a person? I don’t mean the kind of knowing where you ask someone a few questions, and they respond with carefully curated answers, often AI-assisted these days. I mean the kind of knowing that begins when you meet someone in a random place, perhaps on a run or a walk, maybe at a bar, a cooking retreat, an art show, a concert, at the gym, a yoga class, or a book reading. When you ask each other questions as they occur to you, when the conversation takes a turn neither of you anticipated, when the person is fully present before you. Their body, their presence, the whole 3D or 4D or 5D of it.
There is something to be said for the time it takes to discover another person. For the conversation that wanders away from the question you meant to ask, for the peculiar detail that stays with you long after you have forgotten the person’s name, for the way someone might surprise you by being funny when you expected them to be serious. These are small things, perhaps, but they are also the substance of intimacy. You cannot always anticipate them, and you certainly cannot put them all into a profile. I know this sounds hopelessly romantic, and perhaps it is. I am not suggesting that we return to some imagined past in which people met by chance, fell in love, and lived happily ever after. Our parents’ generation had its own difficulties, many of them concealed beneath the practical arrangements and social expectations that kept people together long after love had become difficult or impossible. We should be careful about turning those arrangements into a golden age of human connection.
And yet, somewhere along the way, we seem to have confused the freedom to choose with the obligation to keep choosing. We have taken a genuine expansion of possibility and built an apparatus around it, one that encourages us to keep looking even when we have found someone worth knowing. Perhaps part of the appeal is that the possibility of someone better arriving tomorrow makes it easier to live with the uncertainties of the person standing before us today. A new person comes with the promise of a future we have not yet had the chance to complicate. We have not discovered their habits, their contradictions, the things about them that will test our patience or ask us to reconsider our assumptions. For a little while, they remain almost entirely possibility. The person we have known for years, meanwhile, has become real in all the ways reality can be difficult: familiar, imperfect, capable of disappointing us in ways we could never have anticipated. It is tempting to mistake the promise of the unknown for evidence that something better is waiting elsewhere.
There is a joy in the finding out, in the gradual accumulation of details that make another person familiar to you, and in the occasional surprise of discovering that they are not quite who you had imagined them to be. What is criminal, and I mean that quite deliberately, is how we have gradually relegated this act of knowing, this desire to encounter another person, to a series of questions and answers.
I don’t mean that leaving a relationship is necessarily a failure of commitment. Sometimes leaving is the most necessary thing a person can do. But I wonder whether the constant availability of alternatives has made it harder to distinguish between a relationship that has run its course and one that has simply begun to reveal itself. There is a difference between discovering that you have chosen the wrong person and discovering that the person you chose is more complicated than you imagined. The first might be a reason to leave. The second is often where knowing someone begins. Perhaps this is what I mean when I call it a crime: that somewhere between the certainty with which we once declared our love and the elaborate ways we have now devised for determining who might be worthy of it, we have allowed the machinery of selection to occupy the space once taken up by curiosity. We have begun to think that choosing someone and knowing them are variations of the same activity. They are not. Choosing can happen in an instant. Knowing takes time, and a willingness to be surprised.
I am implicated in this, of course. I have swiped left and right. I have looked at photographs and tried to imagine the person behind them. I have made judgments on the basis of information that, in retrospect, seems absurdly inadequate. And I have been judged in the same way. Living in Kansas and now in Missouri, I became aware of how the assumptions and preferences built into the dating landscape could make certain kinds of connection difficult to imagine, let alone pursue. The algorithms did not invent those biases, but they gave them a system through which to operate. Even so, I kept using the apps. The promise of possibility can be difficult to resist, especially when you are lonely, when you are new to a place, or when you have begun to believe that everyone else has figured out something about love that you have somehow missed. But when I think about the relationships that have mattered most to me, I keep returning to the people I met outside those systems, the friendships that developed before I knew what they would become, the people whose presence gradually acquired meaning. I return to the pleasure of finding out. To the small astonishments of another person, to the realization that there is always more to know than I could have anticipated. Perhaps I am sentimental about this. Perhaps the apps have simply made visible a difficulty that has always existed.






