The Return of Quentin Tarantino’s Imaginary Self
The strange backward cool of Cliff Booth, the murderous stuntman.
November 16, 2026
Note:
No-longer-fresh spoilers ahead.
Jimmy Buffet wrote a song called “He Went to Paris” (1973), about the life of a one-armed Spanish Civil War veteran he claimed to have met. It begins philosophically: “He went to Paris looking for answers / To questions that bothered him so….” Bob Dylan has said he likes Buffet and named this song as a favorite. But Buffet had not been to Paris when he wrote it. Evidently casting about in his imagination for concrete details that would evoke the City of Light, expatriatism, and the good life, he sings in his mild drawl, “The French wahns and cheesus / Put his ambition at bay.”
The combined effect—drawl, narrative cliché, “wines” as homophone for “whines,” and the word “cheeses” (“cheese” is already an “uncountable noun,” like “wine,” but Buffet makes it more plural with the “s,” as if to signal a true gourmand)—is so unintentionally comic that I always pause, boiled shrimp or deep-fried shrimp or spoonful of shrimp gumbo halfway to my mouth, any time the song begins to play in some fish house or beach-themed bar.
Aspects of narrative that strongly call attention to themselves by not fitting in with the ambient tone, action, or characters are a kind of linguistic or dramatic violence that often leans to comedy. Sometimes these are writerly tics, bad impulses, or ignorance; sometimes they are used purposefully for effect (“Exit, pursued by a bear”). Writer-director Quentin Tarantino has made them a living.
Tarantino says he makes two kinds of movies. The first is “realer than real,” as he puts it, with characters plausible enough for viewers to willingly suspend disbelief because they say and do things that humans might do and have recognizable emotional reactions. These include Reservoir Dogs, Pulp Fiction, Inglourious Basterds, and Once Upon a Time in Hollywood. His second kind takes place in a “special movie universe,” i.e., they are genre movies with comic-book or other melodramatic action that Tarantino says his “real” characters would enjoy watching in theaters. These include Kill Bill, From Dusk Till Dawn, Death Proof, and his unproduced western series.
Recently I read Tarantino’s novelization (2021) of his movie Once Upon a Time in Hollywood (2019). The novel, which has the same title, expands on the movie characters’ backstories, records their inner dialogue, and changes the focus of the story.
But it is a Tarantino trademark that even in his “real” movies, big things, odd things, usually improbably violent things, interrupt the narratives, often just as people are having a long conversation slowed to the speed of a stage play. The effect was startling at first. Think of Vincent Vega (John Travolta) in Pulp Fiction (1994) returning from the bathroom to find that his mobster boss’ wife, Mia Wallace (Uma Therman), has OD’d on his, Vincent’s, heroin by mistake. His previous worry—that the two of them feel a forbidden connection after dinner-talk and a kitschy dance contest—has exploded. Now he is full-bore terrified: “If she fucking croaks on me, I’m a grease spot,” he tells his dealer. Everything that follows, up to and including her resurrection-by-epinephrine-to-the-heart, is an out-of-control, darkly comic sequence by Travolta at his panicked best. It ends only when the drug dealer’s wife says in ghoulish catharsis, “That was fuckin’ trippy.” Exactly so.
Tonal shifts, sudden action, and weird characters call attention to themselves over and over in Tarantino’s “real” movies, e.g., the entire “gimp” sequence and Christopher Walken’s “watch” monologue in Pulp Fiction, or the perverse Hans Landa in Inglourious Basterds, who possesses such a specific combination of heightened traits that Tarantino said he despaired of finding an actor who could play the part. In Christoph Waltz, Tarantino finally got his Landa, but the director limited Waltz’s time with the rest of the cast and told him to tone his rehearsals down, so when filming began he would come as a shock to the other actors, as he was to us. Waltz won the movie’s only Oscar for his supporting performance.
Because Tarantino has trained us to expect these disruptions in his work, we watch now with trepidation from the start, most of all when scenes get quiet and characters are calm or are trying to seem calm. It is hard to tell if this is mere audience manipulation or if Tarantino really believes the world is always about to spring terrible news or violence on us.
Recently I read Tarantino’s novelization (2021) of his movie Once Upon a Time in Hollywood (2019). The novel, which has the same title, expands on the movie characters’ backstories, records their inner dialogue, and changes the focus of the story. The Manson Family attack on stuntman Cliff Booth (Brad Pitt) and his boss, actor Rick Dalton (Leonardo DiCaprio), which provides the climax and ending of the movie, is mentioned early and only in passing in the novel. Instead, the encounters between Rick Dalton and his eight-year old co-star in the western series within the movie become a pedophilia-tinged relationship, which the novel wants us to believe makes Dalton unexpectedly grateful for his life and craft.
The tone is grotesque, and Roman Polanski is already a character, and so are the teen/runaway “Manson girls,” one of whom, a minor, offers oral sex (movie) or masturbatory voyeurism (novel) to Cliff Booth in exchange for a ride. In both movie and novel Rick Dalton also acts with James Stacy, a real actor who in 1995 was convicted of child molestation. In the novel, Cliff Booth is interested in learning how to pimp women but decides not to, only because it is too much work. Tarantino’s story threatens to become “about” sexual predation, minus narratorial perspective, plus other misogyny in word and deed. (Rick Dalton calls the little girl the worst of names in the novel; ditto Cliff Booth and his wife.)
You might recall Tarantino’s angry response to Spike Lee’s criticism of his hyper-use of a racial slur (“…Quentin is infatuated with the word. What does he want? To be made an honorary black man?”) in his 1997 movie Jackie Brown.
“As a writer, I demand the right to write any character in the world that I want to write,” Tarantino replied through the press. “And to say that I can’t do that because I’m white…that is racist.”
Lee added, in a 2012 article published by the UK Independent, “…I think something is wrong with him…. He says he grew up on Blaxploitation films and that they were his favorite films but he has to realise that those films do not speak to the…African-American experience. I mean the guy’s just stupid.”
The idea that “something is wrong” with Tarantino has come up often in regard to other non-plot preoccupations, such as the choking of actresses and highlighting their feet on film, and his Žižek-like manner in talking about his work. Tarantino’s fascination with the illicit and the violent, and his defensive insistence on fetishizing them as entertainments, even when they do not serve a narrative, have always seemed like aspects of a person who fears what may be in himself, the world, or both.
As I read the novel, I noted the emphasis and tone of a scene where Cliff Booth learns the impossible backstory of “Pussycat,” a hippie girl he is giving a ride. Cliff asks the teen how she got involved with the Manson Family, and after listening to her story, he sums it up:
“Okay, let me get this straight: A dude [Pussycat’s father] picks up a hippie [Manson] hitchhiking? He takes the hippie home for dinner with his wife and his fourteen-year-old daughter? The hippie fucks the fourteen-year-old girl and takes off with her in the dude’s car [that same night]? The same car that gave him a lift? Because of the hippie, the daughter gets married at fifteen [to be emancipated from her parents] and then runs off with the hippie? The dude’s wife leaves him due to all the chaos he caused by giving that fucking hippie a ride? The dude tracks the hippie down with a shotgun, but instead of blowing his head off, he later drops acid and parties with the hippie? And then later asks to be one of the hippie’s disciples?” (307)
Because this anecdote is very close to the actual historical record (Manson in fact kissed the father’s toes, which Tarantino seems to have missed), I can hear Tarantino’s own wonder, almost fear, in Cliff Booth’s astonishment that such things can occur. This and other aspects of the novel suggest that Tarantino wrote the book (“based on the film”) to explore things he did not resolve to his satisfaction or get enough of in the movie. (In one deleted scene from the movie, Charles Manson, driving a busted Twinkie truck, has a direct encounter with Cliff Booth. There is no similar encounter in the final cut. Cliff does not laugh off Manson’s weird performance as he does, say, Bruce Lee’s in the film. The deleted scene and the novel want it known that Cliff understands the threat and instinctively takes Manson’s nonsense seriously.)
Tarantino’s fascination with the illicit and the violent, and his defensive insistence on fetishizing them as entertainments, even when they do not serve a narrative, have always seemed like aspects of a person who fears what may be in himself, the world, or both.
Fans have shown love for Cliff Booth on social media since the movie came out. Booth has had stunt adventures, can fight when necessary, and is able to fix things around Rick’s house. He loves his dog. Brad Pitt was 55 when he played the role but was of course still youthful-looking and in terrific shape, a golden boy in a story sentimental about California in the sixties. Pitt’s Booth is eminently more likable than Leonardo DiCaprio’s Rick Dalton, who is a boozer, hack, and self-hating neurotic. (In the novel, Dalton is even grosser and more ignorant.) Many viewers believe Once is chiefly about the two characters’ friendship, which is unequal and lets Rick abandon Cliff, despite their long history. This too increases sympathy for Cliff.
A representative video on YouTube, titled “A MASTERCLASS in FRIENDSHIP (Cliff Booth Character Appreciation),” says, “Being in control is one of those key skills that all great men possess. It’s also one of the hardest to master. You see, being a good man means you make sacrifices. […] It means that no matter what life throws at you, you stay calm. You stay cool. Now, Cliff Booth is the epitome of cool. […] He’s the kind of guy we secretly or in this case openly aspire to be. […] While we could all use a friend like Cliff, I’m afraid men like him are becoming scarcer by the minute. [L]et me know what other great manly characters you want me to tackle next time.”
Brad Pitt says of playing Cliff Booth, “[J]ust where I am in my life, I was…really drawn to him. I love what Quentin had written [presumably in the screenplay]; it was a guy who was pretty at peace with his place in life, knew what he was dedicated to, what he was not dedicated to, looked for the best in people but was not surprised to get the worst in people. I could relate to that.”
But in the movie, Cliff killed his wife “and got away with it.” The second part of that sentence seems more impressive to other characters than the first, since it can only mean murder. Her death is not shown, though the seconds before it are: Cliff with a beer in one hand and his finger on the trigger of a speargun pointed at her abdomen, while she rails at him in anger. He looks “calm,” “cool,” and “pretty at peace” behind an unnecessary skindiving mask. But what kind of character is Cliff Booth if he did murder his wife? What kind of character is he if he accidentally killed her due to lacking the “key skill” of weapon discipline, especially as a veteran and a stuntman? Actor and fans may see Cliff as loyal, fair, disciplined, and laid-back, but Rick Dalton spends significant energy in the movie trying to talk others out of the idea that Cliff is a really bad guy. (“Misadventure,” the wife chapter in the novel is titled, legally “a death due to unintentional accident without any violation of law or criminal negligence. Thus, there is no crime.”)
If we believe Tarantino’s novel is the same world as the one in his movie, it gets much worse. Cliff Booth is not only a murderer but something close to a serial killer. He tells two Italian-American “hoodlums” giving him a hard time in a Cleveland pizza joint, “When I was in Sicily [in WWII], I killed Italians every day. […] And I was in Sicily a long, long time.” After showing them one of his two “Medals of Valor” from the war, he shoots them both in their heads, then shoots each twice more for good measure (and gets away with it).
After Italy, we learn, he went to the Pacific Theater, where he killed more Japanese “than any other American serviceman,” and beheaded his former captors. Not long before we meet him, he has killed a fellow stuntman in a fight in his trailer and dumped his body. Then there was his wife: “The minute Cliff shot his wife with the shark gun, he knew it was a bad idea.” (152) He finally (for now) kills and maims two of the three Manson hippies when they break into Rick’s house. Does Tarantino believe that this character, who has killed dozens of people, can be considered a nice guy? Is that still within the idea of “real,” or is it more accurate to call it a Tarantino fantasy of two (or more) entirely different types combined into one?
I mentioned to a friend who is a couple of years out of college that the character of Cliff Booth had begun to make me think instead of Marvel movies, in which characters such as Drax the Destroyer go from being intergalactic murderers to finders of lost children and all-around swell folk.
Does Tarantino believe that this character, who has killed dozens of people, can be considered a nice guy? Is that still within the idea of “real,” or is it more accurate to call it a Tarantino fantasy of two (or more) entirely different types combined into one?
“Capeshit,” the young man said. “That’s the term my generation uses for any of that superhero garbage with unrealistic psychology, unoriginal slop-plots, and constant violence. I cannot stand that stuff. And Tarantino is disgusting, you can see it in his physiognomy.”
In the novel, Tarantino (or at least his narrator, who sounds exactly like Tarantino on one of his didactic rips), seems to identify with Cliff Booth, who in addition to being a nice guy and a terrible killer has excellent, informed tastes and wide interests in world cinema, so he can serve as geeked-out mouthpiece for Tarantino’s own film analysis and deep knowledge of Hollywood trivia. This sort of thing goes on for more than a dozen pages at a time. Funnily enough, Booth’s judgements on the immaturity of American movies by directors who have never experienced war or violence first-hand, compared to films made in other countries (including Booth’s former foes’), seem to be admired but not followed by Tarantino the writer-director. Booth understands violence; Tarantino seems afraid of it at an almost existential level and often makes it ridiculous.
Tarantino has acknowledged that several characters in his movies are related, and it occurs to me that both Cliff Booth in Once and Lt. Aldo Raine in Inglourious look like Brad Pitt (because they are Brad Pitt). They are of the same dramatic age, and both fought through Sicily in WWII to (apparently) become special forces later. Both characters are portrayed as pragmatists who say things like, “What’s done is done.” Might they be cousins? Raine likes to carve swastikas into foreheads, as Manson did, and says at the end of Inglourious one of the most self-referential lines in Tarantino’s oeuvre, “I think this might just be my masterpiece,” as he breaks the fourth wall and stares down into our eyes as if we are his victim. This is followed by the end-credit card that reads, “Written and Directed by Quentin Tarantino.” It is the closest Tarantino ever got to being Booth/Raine/Pitt.
Now the sequel/spin-off to Once Upon a Time in Hollywood is coming out on IMAX in theaters over Thanksgiving. Tarantino’s novelization of the new movie will drop on December 8. The movie will begin streaming on Netflix on December 23.
The sequel, called The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth, was written by Tarantino but was directed this time by David Fincher (Fight Club, The Social Network, Girl with the Dragon Tattoo, Gone Girl, et al). Brad Pitt reprises his role as Cliff Booth (somewhat puzzlingly, given the nasty revelations of the first novel) and served as producer for the sequel. We will have to wait to see which Cliff Booth shows up.






